Support 7804j · Oct 27, 2026 · on this version · The proposal has changed since. View changes
META — PAGE ABOUT AGPEDIA
Proposal: Follow the comments on a page
Adopted, not yet applied
decided on October 27, 2026 by 7804j
- Pull requests
Adopted: supported by OKA, with no objection raised. Being built in pull request #104.
What changes
Every page gets a Follow button, next to the Discuss tab. Following a page means you are notified when someone comments on it:
- a new discussion thread about the page, and every comment in its discussion threads;
- on a proposal, a new or changed position, and every reply to a position;
- later, comments under articles, once Comments under articles is built.
Following is about the conversation, not the text. Edits to the page don't notify you. That is the difference from Wikipedia's watchlist.
Who follows what automatically
- The person who created the page follows the whole page. Whoever writes a proposal hears about every position and reply on it.
- Anyone else who comments follows only their own conversation. If you post a position, you are told about replies to your position. If you post in a discussion thread, you are told about new comments in that thread. You are not told about other positions or other threads on the page, unless you click Follow.
The button shows whether you follow the page, and one click stops following it. A list of the pages you follow is in your settings, where you can stop following any of them.
Why
Today, the person who writes a proposal is not told when someone posts a position on it, changes their position, or opens a discussion thread about it. Only replies inside a forum thread notify, and only the people already in that thread. So proposers have to keep checking their pages by hand, and questions go unanswered.
How it works
- A notification says what happened and where, for example "anothereditor posted a position (Oppose) on Proposal: Redirects and renames", and links straight to it.
- You are never notified about your own comments.
- If several things happen on the same page before you look, you get one notification per comment, as for forum replies today. Grouping them can come later if it gets noisy.
- The new kind of notification, comments on pages you follow, gets its own choice in your notification settings: on the site, by email, or both.
- Following a page also follows its discussion threads, so you don't get the same comment twice.
Technical notes
A page subscription table (user, page) sits beside the existing forum thread subscriptions. Page creators are subscribed to the page when it is created, and existing pages are backfilled for their first author. Posting a position, a reply or a comment subscribes the author to that thread only, as forum threads do today, never to the whole page. The notification queue gets one new kind, page.comment; a comment notifies the union of the page's and the thread's followers, once each, minus its author.
Positions
Discussion1 support 0 neutral 0 oppose
Available in