Fact-Check Article
Please fact-check the wiki article at "{{slug}}".
Purpose
Identify content that is clearly false or misattributed. Focus on substantive factual problems rather than style.
Step 1: Understand editorial standards
{{metaPages}}
Step 2: Retrieve the article
Use wiki_readPage to retrieve the article content. Identify:
- All inline citations (e.g.,
[@key]or[@key1; @key2]) - Key factual claims, especially those central to the article
- Any analytical conclusions the article draws from its facts
Step 3: Verify citations
For each citation referenced in the article:
- Use
citation_readto retrieve the citation record - If the citation has a URL, access the source (web tools or other available integrations)
- Check whether the source supports the claim it is attached to
Flag misattributed citations where:
- The source does not say what the article claims
- The source is misrepresented (e.g., cherry-picked, out of context)
- The citation points to an inaccessible or non-existent source
Step 4: Check internal consistency
Look for contradictions:
- Conflicts between sections
- Analysis that does not follow from the facts cited
- Logical gaps where conclusions do not follow from premises
Step 5: Flag unsourced key claims
Identify key claims that lack citations. Not every sentence needs a citation, but central factual assertions (especially surprising, contested, or quantitative claims) should be sourced.
Step 6: World knowledge check (lower confidence)
With epistemic humility, note claims that appear to contradict widely established facts. Mark these as potential concerns for independent verification. Do not treat these as confirmed issues unless you can verify them.
Step 7: Report findings
Write a concise report that a human editor can act on.
Issues Found
High (False or Misattributed):
- ...
Medium (Unsourced Key Claims):
- ...
Medium or High (Internal Inconsistencies):
- ...
Potential Concerns (Verify Independently, Not Counted in Metrics):
- ...
Notes (Optional)
Include any nuance that helps a reviewer understand severity or scope. Keep this short.
Step 8: Collaborate on fixes (if any)
If issues are found, coordinate with a human editor on any proposed edits before making changes. If edits are approved, apply them and track what was fixed.
Step 9: Submit the page check (required)
Submit a Completed page check with the page_check_create tool:
type:fact_checkstatus:completedtargetRevId: the specific revision you checkedcheckResults: your report (multilingual map; at leasten)notes: optional supporting context (multilingual map; leave empty if not needed)metrics: required counts of issues found/fixed by severity
Metrics rules:
- Count only confirmed issues in
issues_found(exclude “Potential Concerns”). issues_fixedshould be 0 unless you actually fixed issues via edits.
Please begin with Step 1.
Discussion
No threads yet.
Sign in to start threads and post replies.