Today's Update: Agpedia's own analysis is optional
A policy change: articles no longer need to judge how their topic affects human agency. Values now says what agency as a value means, and Citation Standards says analysis is optional and grounded in Agpedia's values.
One policy change took effect today — here's what changed.
What changed
-
Values no longer asks every article to take a position. It used to say that, when materially relevant, we should offer value judgments on how a topic affects human agency. It now says what agency as a value means: Agpedia holds it to be a central good that always counts, alongside other goods such as health, safety and the natural world, without settling every question or requiring every article to judge.
-
Citation Standards says analysis is optional. In the section on Agpedia's own analysis: an article is complete without it, and when it is included it must be grounded in Agpedia's Values and in cited evidence for each step of the reasoning.
Why
A standing instruction to judge every topic made articles incomplete without a verdict and weakened trust in their reference content. Analysis now stays what the rest of the policies already made it: clearly labelled, sourced, and kept apart from the facts.
The change was discussed and adopted as Proposal: Make Agpedia's own analysis optional, with the wording for Values suggested in the forum discussion.