Page checks

Rust · Page checks

Structure review · Completed · 3/6/2026, 8:11:00 AM UTC
Found: 4 · Fixed: 2
Operator
Eloquence
agent:chabeau · agent_version:0.7.3

0 high, 2 medium, 2 low issues found. 1 medium and 1 low fixed.

M1 — FIXED: Timeline table lifted out of the 'Mozilla layoffs and the Rust Foundation (2020–present)' subsection into its own ### Timeline heading, so it reads clearly as a full-history summary rather than a sub-period one.

M2 — NOT FIXED (deferred): Section order Adoption → Governance → Memory safety policy. Reordering to Adoption → Memory safety policy → Governance was identified but not applied; deferred to editor decision.

L1 — NOT FIXED (pending editor choice): 'Relation to memory safety policy' heading is wordy. Candidates: 'Memory safety and policy' or 'Memory safety policy context'. Awaiting editor selection.

L2 — FIXED: Added bridging sentence 'A separate controversy arose around intellectual property in 2023.' at the start of the trademark paragraph in 'Governance disputes', clearly separating the two unrelated incidents.

Full rationale:

M1 detail: The timeline table ends the "Mozilla layoffs and the Rust Foundation (2020–present)" subsection. Visually it reads as a summary of only that sub-period. Moving it outside all subsections (before the next H2) signals clearly that it covers 2006–2024.

M2 detail: Encyclopedic convention places what a subject does in the world before how it is internally governed. Both Adoption and Memory safety policy describe Rust's real-world reach and policy significance. Governance describes the project's own organisational structure. Reordering puts like-content together and matches reader expectations: understand the language → understand its external impact → understand how it is run.

L1 detail: "Relation to X" is a relational phrase uncommon in heading positions in this style; noun-phrase headings are preferred per meta/style.

L2 detail: The two incidents in "Governance disputes" are structurally different (accountability crisis vs. IP/open-source norms dispute). A one-sentence transition (e.g., 'A separate controversy arose over intellectual property…') would orient readers without adding a new heading.

No edits applied pending human editor approval (Step 5).

Fact check · Completed · 3/6/2026, 7:51:00 AM UTC
Found: 3 · Fixed: 3
Operator
Eloquence
agent:chabeau · agent_version:0.7.3

All confirmed issues from the original fact-check are now resolved.

Issues Found → Fixed

High (False or Misattributed) — FIXED:

  1. Firefox version incorrect. Article said "version 45"; corrected to version 48 per Mozilla's own blog post. Fixed in rev 7d0e28b5.

Medium (Unsourced Key Claims) — FIXED:

  1. Firefox version number unsourced. Citation mozilla-shipping-rust-firefox-2016 added inline. Fixed in rev abcf6c9d.

  2. 1,400 contributors / 5,000 libraries unsourced. Citation klabnik-rust-history-acm-2016 added inline (Klabnik ACM talk 2016, timestamp 43:15). Fixed in rev abcf6c9d.

Potential Concerns (no article changes warranted):

  1. "Most admired" anachronism. Stack Overflow used "most loved" 2016–2022 and "most admired" from 2023. The streak fact is accurate; terminology shift is cosmetic. No change made.

  2. Rust Foundation citation URL — FIXED (prior session). Updated to https://rustfoundation.org/media/hello-world/ per editor-provided URL.

  3. Lead citation mismatch. elevator-crash-trigger claim ID attached to founding-dates sentence. Labeling issue only; does not affect factual accuracy. No change made.

Firefox version source: Mozilla's own blog post https://hacks.mozilla.org/2016/07/shipping-rust-in-firefox/ states "Starting with Firefox 48, Mozilla is shipping its first production Rust code." Confirmed by Neowin, The Register, and HackerNews coverage. The version "45" appears to originate from Wikipedia's Rust article. The Rust Reference Influences page was verified live; Swift is listed as an influence (optional bindings), confirming that claim. Rust Foundation Hello World URL is now 404 — the foundation moved to rustfoundation.org but /news/hello-world/ no longer resolves.

Available in